To Engineer Is Human

The Role of Failure in Successful Design

Henry Petroski

21 min read
1m 41s intro

Brief summary

To Engineer Is Human argues that progress in engineering comes from studying failure, not ignoring it. Through examples from bridges to aircraft, it reveals how every design is a balance of tradeoffs and how learning from mistakes makes structures safer.

Who it's for

This book is for anyone curious about how the physical world is designed, built, and improved, from engineers to everyday observers of bridges and buildings.

To Engineer Is Human

Audio & text in the Readsome app

Introduction: Why We Build and Why Things Break

Engineering is a deeply human activity, driven by changing tastes, limited resources, and the ambition to build bigger or more efficient structures. Unlike the design of a beehive, which remains the same for generations, human construction is always evolving. Henry Petroski observes that because our desires for fashion and economy change, the way we build must also change. This constant evolution is what makes the field exciting, but it also introduces new ways for things to go wrong. Because humans are involved in every step of the process, the products of engineering are naturally subject to human error.

The responsibility for these errors has been recognized for thousands of years. In ancient Babylon, the Code of Hammurabi imposed the death penalty on builders if a house they constructed collapsed and killed the owner. Today, the consequences are usually financial or professional rather than physical, involving massive lawsuits and the loss of engineering licenses. Despite the headlines that follow a major disaster, like a hotel walkway collapse or a plane crash, these events are incredibly rare. Statistically, a person is much safer inside a modern building than driving a car, yet we are often more frightened by structural failures because they are unfamiliar and unexpected.

A major challenge in creating safe structures is the balance between cost and absolute security. It is technically possible to make every bridge and building many times stronger than necessary, but doing so would be extremely expensive and would result in heavy, unattractive designs. There is a constant tension between the desire for perfect safety and the reality of limited budgets. This conflict is visible in our daily lives, such as when we choose to drive smaller, cheaper cars that might be less safe than larger, more expensive ones. When safety is neglected to save money, especially in aging infrastructure like city water pipes, the eventual failures can cause massive economic disruption.

We are all engineers by nature because the principles of machines and structures are built into our very bones. From the moment of birth, we learn to hold our bodies against the forces of gravity, calculating the movement of our limbs with a precision that often exceeds advanced technology. As infants, we experience the world through the lifting and carrying of the adults who transport us. We are moved across impromptu bridges made of human arms, trusting in the strength of our parents long before we understand physics. Our bodies serve as our first engineering laboratories, where every stumble and fall provides data on how to maintain balance.

Childhood play further refines this understanding of structural limits. Whether building with simple wooden blocks or complex plastic sets, children learn the limitations of different materials. Playing with mud and clay teaches the properties of masonry, while watching flowers sway on green stalks demonstrates how columns support weight. Fairy tales also provide sophisticated lessons in design and safety. The story of the Three Little Pigs highlights the importance of designing for extreme conditions, proving that over-designing a structure can be the difference between survival and disaster.

Full summary available in the Readsome app

Get it on Google PlayDownload on the App Store

About the author

Henry Petroski

Henry Petroski was an American engineer and professor of civil engineering and history at Duke University, specializing in failure analysis. A prolific author, he was known for his writings and lectures on the importance of failure in the engineering design process, making complex engineering concepts accessible to the general public. His work aimed to explain the nature of invention and engineering by examining the history and design of objects ranging from large structures to everyday items.

Similar book summaries