Wonderful Life

The Burgess Shale and the Nature of History

Stephen Jay Gould

18 min read
1m 23s intro

Brief summary

Wonderful Life uses fossils from the Burgess Shale to argue that evolution is not a predictable march toward complexity, but a contingent history shaped by chance and mass extinction. Early animal life began with far more anatomical diversity than survives today, and our own existence is the result of a highly improbable series of events.

Who it's for

This book is for anyone interested in evolution, paleontology, and the history and philosophy of science.

Wonderful Life

Audio & text in the Readsome app

The Discovery of the Burgess Shale

About 570 million years ago, the fossil record shows a sudden and massive surge in the variety of animal life known as the Cambrian explosion. Most of what we know about ancient life comes from hard parts like shells and bones, which offer a very limited view of what an animal actually looked like. The Burgess Shale, located in the Canadian Rockies, is a rare and precious exception to this rule. Because it preserved the soft tissues of creatures in exquisite detail, it provides a clear view into the true nature of early evolution.

When Charles Doolittle Walcott first discovered these fossils in 1909, he found them in one of the most majestic settings in North America. Located high in the mountains within Yoho National Park, the site overlooks vibrant lakes and snow-capped peaks. Walcott was so captivated by the area that he returned year after year well into his seventies to spend his summers living in tents and working the mountain ridges. The preservation of these fossils in such a location was a rare stroke of geological luck.

These ancient animals originally lived on mud banks at the base of a massive underwater cliff. In their natural habitat, these creatures would typically decay or be eaten by scavengers, leaving no trace for the future. However, a local mudslide likely swept these animals into a nearby basin that was stagnant and completely devoid of oxygen. This rapid burial in an environment where nothing could live or rot allowed their delicate soft tissues to be preserved for over 500 million years.

Despite the incredible preservation, early interpretations of the fossils were deeply flawed. Walcott tried to fit every specimen into existing categories of modern animals, viewing these ancient creatures as simple ancestors of the animals we see today. He even misidentified parts of a single large predator, Anomalocaris, as two separate animals because he was so intent on finding familiar ancestors. Later research overturned this traditional view, revealing that the Burgess Shale actually contained a much wider range of anatomical designs than exists in all our modern oceans combined.

To see this full picture of ancient life, scientists rely on rare geological sites that preserve soft parts like skin, guts, and delicate limbs. Without soft tissues, it is nearly impossible to understand how ancient creatures actually functioned or how many different types truly existed. The Burgess Shale reveals that the early history of life was a unique period of massive anatomical experimentation. Once that initial burst ended, nature stopped inventing new basic blueprints and instead spent the next 500 million years fine-tuning the few designs that happened to survive.

Full summary available in the Readsome app

Get it on Google PlayDownload on the App Store

About the author

Stephen Jay Gould

Stephen Jay Gould was an American paleontologist, evolutionary biologist, and historian of science who spent most of his career teaching at Harvard University. His most significant contribution to evolutionary biology is the theory of punctuated equilibrium, developed with Niles Eldredge, which proposes that evolution occurs in rapid bursts followed by long periods of stability. Gould was also one of the most influential and widely read popular science authors of his generation, known for his numerous essays and books.

Similar book summaries