Should I Stay or Should I Go?

A Guide to Working Out Whether Your Relationship Can--and Should--be Saved

Lundy Bancroft, Jac Patrissi

16 min read
1m 22s intro

Brief summary

This book argues that the right question is not whether a troubled relationship can be saved, but whether it provides safety, respect, honesty, and room for your life to grow. It offers clear standards for distinguishing healthy conflict from harmful patterns of control, immaturity, and abuse.

Who it's for

This is for anyone who feels stuck, confused, or drained by a difficult relationship and needs clarity on whether to stay or leave.

Should I Stay or Should I Go?

Audio & text in the Readsome app

Introduction: Evaluating Your Relationship

Many women face ongoing frustration and confusion in their relationships, wondering if their partner is a good match or if the struggle is worth the effort. Lundy Bancroft explains that these feelings often stem from specific behaviors, such as a partner who keeps his distance, fails to take responsibility, or acts in ways that cause insecurity. While every relationship begins with high hopes, the reality of constant conflict can be overwhelming. It is important to distinguish between normal growing pains and deep-seated problems that require significant change.

A healthy relationship relies on essential elements like mutual respect, safety, equality, and kindness. Both partners should feel free to express their true thoughts and prioritize one another. While disagreements are natural, they should not involve one person putting the other down or creating fear. When these basics are missing, the issue often lies in immaturity, addiction, mental health struggles, or abusive patterns.

Every relationship experiences tension, but there is a clear distinction between the normal growing pains of a healthy partnership and the destructive cycles of an unhealthy one. In a healthy relationship, couples typically move through three predictable stages. It begins with a romantic stage, a short-lived but intense period where everything feels perfect and differences seem trivial. This naturally leads to a conflict stage, where partners feel vulnerable and begin to notice their differences in values, habits, or goals. Finally, they reach an evaluating commitment stage, where they decide if the relationship is satisfying enough to sustain.

In contrast, unhealthy relationships often spiral downward instead of growing stronger. While they may start with a powerful romantic phase, the conflict stage reveals that the couple is not actually a team. Signs of trouble include arguments focused on winning rather than solving problems, one partner being consistently explosive or secretive, and a lack of accountability where everything is blamed on the other person. In these dynamics, a woman often feels she is walking on eggshells, wondering what she did wrong while her self-esteem steadily declines.

To find clarity, you must stop waiting for things to change and instead treat the relationship like an investigation. This involves shifting the focus from managing the partner’s moods to pursuing your own personal goals. By actively moving toward your own dreams, you create an experiment that reveals the truth of the relationship. A supportive partner will cheer you on, while a destructive one will likely try to sabotage your progress or complain of abandonment.

It is also essential to distinguish between realistic needs and movie-style fantasies. No partner can be your only source of happiness, solve all your problems, or love every single thing about you. However, you have an absolute right to certain bottom-line requirements. These include being treated with consistent respect, feeling physically and emotionally safe, and feeling loved and seen the majority of the time.

Full summary available in the Readsome app

Get it on Google PlayDownload on the App Store

About the author

Lundy Bancroft

Lundy Bancroft is an author, workshop leader, and consultant with over thirty years of experience in the fields of domestic abuse and child maltreatment. He is a former co-director of Emerge, the first counseling program in the United States for men who batter, and has worked with over a thousand abusive men as a counselor and clinical supervisor. Bancroft's work focuses on accountability for abusive men, the healing of women and children, and training for professionals, including judges, therapists, and law enforcement, on best practices for intervention.

Similar book summaries